The Witcher S04 — New Face, Old Wounds: Can the Series Survive the Geralt Swap?

SERIES REVIEW – Netflix’s fourth season picks up where the world is still cracked, and hearts stitch themselves back together slower than the seams of a battered plate. Liam Hemsworth takes up the sword and the restrained growl, while Ciri and Yennefer’s paths bend back toward each other — with more blood, betrayal, and wounds that refuse to heal. The question isn’t whether fresh monsters appear; it’s whether the series can recover the pulse it lost when Henry Cavill departed.

 

The season opener lays down its battle lines within minutes: the moral gray is thicker than ever, and choices snap like a silver blade pulled a beat too soon. A narrator dredges up old tales while the legend wears a new face — not the myth being rewritten so much as audience expectations shifting. The stakes are the same as ever: preserve the fragile “family” that makes this world barely livable.

 

“Always Lost, Never Found” — Family In The Storm, Bloodline In The Crosshairs

 

At the center remains the improvised family. Geralt and Yennefer are bound not only by magic and desire, but by the stubborn hope that Ciri will stop running and finally make harbor. Meanwhile, Ciri sheds her name and, under the alias “Falka,” drifts in with the Rats — a crooked crew of antiheroes where growing up isn’t initiation so much as bruising. “Always lost, never found,” she says; it reads less like a complaint than a test of identity.

Geralt recruits the way he knows how: not flawless champions, but hardened survivors who aren’t out to write a fairy tale — they’re trying to bring someone home, someone with prophecies pounding in her veins. Yennefer, for her part, faces Vilgefortz, whose cool logic hides an insatiable appetite for power; Ciri’s Elder Blood isn’t a trophy but a key, one that could open far too many locks.

 

Box-Ticking And New Favorites — When The Side Quest Keeps The Main Thread Alive

 

The show is still a knot of quests and side quests; sometimes it behaves like a map, other times a cul-de-sac. With both the books and the games baked into its DNA, a small army of pieces moves across the board — the mosaic slips now and then, yet momentum builds. Fan favorites are only now truly stepping onstage, while Ciri’s stint with the Rats gives the coming-of-age beats a rough edge: loss, doubt, and knife-thin wins.

Inevitably, the threads twist toward a reckoning with Vilgefortz, while reuniting the “family” feels less like a promise and more like settling a debt — to themselves and to each other. The tempo isn’t always tight, but the heading is clear; when it clicks, the world-building reminds you why so many have stayed since season one.

 

Liam Hemsworth As Geralt — A New Face, Different Emphases

 

There’s no dodging it: the headline this year is Geralt’s new face. Hemsworth has a classic leading-man presence, but his gaze is softer; the weight of muscle and old scars sits lighter on him. His voice rides higher, the growl more restrained; where Cavill could conjure a universe with a single gravelly grunt, Hemsworth assembles nuance from smaller moves. It’s a gutsy handoff worthy of respect, yet many will miss the gravitational center that once held scenes together.

That’s also where the production’s weak spots show. The imagery leans sterile, costumes and makeup can look a touch too fresh for the miles they’ve logged, and the color work sometimes sands down the blood and muck that should cling. “Life is filth and blood and death,” Ciri says — but the screen doesn’t always let you smell it.

 

Set-Up For The Finale Or A Late Resurrection?

 

It’s official: season five will close the book. This chapter plays like the anteroom to that ending — too often checking boxes instead of telling the tale. Swordplay and creature design still spark joy, but the series needs to claw back the raw charge that once made it hit. If it tightens up for the finish, it can win its argument with itself; if not, this remains a competent yet tired step toward an inevitable endgame.

-Gergely Herpai BadSector-

The Witcher S04

Direction
Actors
Story
Visuals/action/music/audio
Ambiance

MEDIOCRE

The fourth season’s biggest gamble is the new Geralt: Hemsworth holds his own, but he doesn’t match Cavill’s heft. The Ciri/Rats arc carries the real emotional charge, while the world often feels too sterile for the brutality it claims. As the finale approaches, this is a serviceable but uneven chapter and a reminder that the ending still has to prove itself.

User Rating: Be the first one !

Avatar photo
BadSector is a seasoned journalist for more than twenty years. He communicates in English, Hungarian and French. He worked for several gaming magazines - including the Hungarian GameStar, where he worked 8 years as editor. (For our office address, email and phone number check out our impressum)

No comments

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.