It seems that nobody wants Microsoft’s new AI. While it is being touted as the future of Xbox game development, Muse is facing severe criticism from developers. This generative AI aims to assist studios in creating game content, but the industry’s response has been anything but positive.

Just yesterday, Microsoft unveiled Muse, a generative artificial intelligence designed to aid in the development of Xbox games. It’s a major project that Microsoft has been working on for years, investing billions into AI technology. However, the response from developers has been overwhelmingly negative. Many question not only whether anyone would actually use it, but also if it even has a future in the industry.

Developers Reject AI Once Again

As Brenda Giacconi reported yesterday, Muse can understand in-game physics and 3D environments, allowing it to generate real-time images and reactions. Microsoft showcased its capabilities using Ninja Theory’s Bleeding Edge, demonstrating how the AI can create game elements that can either be used as-is or serve as structural support in larger projects.

Despite Microsoft’s enthusiasm, the developer community has largely rejected the initiative. Many view it as a direct threat to creativity and job security. David Goldfarb, founder of The Outsiders and creator of Metal: Hellsinger, didn’t hold back in his criticism: “Fuck this shit, nobody wants Microsoft’s AI.” As reported by Wired, other developers have echoed similar concerns, arguing that generative AI does not provide real value to creators and instead exists purely to cut costs for corporations.

Fears of Job Loss Continue to Grow

As multiple reports have indicated, the gaming industry has experienced massive layoffs over the past few years, and the increasing implementation of AI has only heightened concerns over job security. An anonymous developer told Wired that within Microsoft, there is a climate of silence surrounding the issue: “Everyone is afraid to speak out against this and lose their job.”

Another developer, also speaking anonymously, described an industry where workers feel pressured to stay quiet to avoid professional consequences. “They don’t realize that nobody wants this. They don’t care that nobody wants this… Internal discussions about these topics are hushed because everyone is afraid that opposing AI will cost them their job, especially given how unstable the industry is right now,” they explained.

Despite the pushback, Microsoft remains committed to Muse as a core tool in game development. The company argues that generative AI can streamline prototyping, enabling studios to iterate on their ideas more rapidly. However, some industry veterans, such as Marc Burrage from Creative Assembly (Total War series), emphasize that human experience remains essential in the creative process and that AI cannot replace the lessons learned through development iterations.

The debate over AI in game development is far from settled. While Microsoft pushes forward with Muse, developers are making their opposition increasingly clear.

Source: 3djuegos