John Wayne Believed One of His Own Films Was the Greatest Western Ever Made

MOVIE NEWS – John Wayne’s rise to superstardom came in 1939 with Stagecoach, the Western that marked his first collaboration with director John Ford. The film’s success sparked a decades-long partnership between the two, leading to several classics, including the 1952 romantic drama The Quiet Man, which earned Ford his fourth Academy Award for Best Director.

 

However, the most defining collaboration between Ford and Wayne is undoubtedly the 1956 Western The Searchers, widely considered one of the greatest and most influential films of the genre. In it, Wayne delivers one of his most powerful performances as Ethan Edwards, a hardened and prejudiced Civil War veteran who embarks on a relentless, years-long quest to rescue his kidnapped niece after their family is slaughtered by Comanche warriors.

Beyond its breathtaking cinematography and meticulous composition, The Searchers is best remembered as an unflinching study of obsession and vengeance. Ethan’s pursuit is fueled by his deep-seated racist hatred for Native Americans—a perspective that, while jarring by modern standards, reflected widely held attitudes at the time of the film’s release in 1956.

 

John Wayne Declared The Searchers the Greatest Western Ever Made

 

By 1977, The Searchers had already been acknowledged as a masterpiece when Wayne was asked to list his five greatest films of all time. His selection included A Man for All Seasons, The Four Horsemen of the Apocalypse, Gone with the Wind, The Quiet Man, and The Searchers—his lone Western pick. While some may have seen his choice as self-serving, time has validated Wayne’s perspective.

His nuanced portrayal of Ethan Edwards encapsulates the film’s central themes of hatred, loss, and redemption. Set in 1868 in West Texas, the story follows Ethan, a former Confederate soldier returning to his brother Aaron’s homestead. Secretly in love with Aaron’s wife Martha, Ethan initially settles into the role of an affectionate uncle to their children, Ben, Lucy, and Debbie. However, his deeply ingrained prejudice surfaces when he meets Martin Pawley, Aaron and Martha’s adopted son, who is part Cherokee—something Ethan considers unforgivable.

Director John Ford does not excuse Ethan’s racism but instead forces audiences to grapple with the duality of his character: a deeply flawed man driven by hate yet capable of devotion. Ethan’s resentment toward Martin is put to the test when Comanche warriors kill Aaron and his family, abducting Lucy and Debbie. As Ethan and Martin set out to find them, their uneasy partnership becomes central to the film’s moral conflict.

Eventually, they locate Debbie, now living among the Comanche and married to a warrior named Scar. Lucy, meanwhile, has been killed. Ethan’s immediate reaction is to murder Debbie, believing death preferable to assimilation. From this point on, Martin’s sole mission is to stop Ethan from carrying out his violent intentions.

Ethan’s defining moment of transformation occurs in the climactic scene when, after defeating Scar, he finds Debbie. Instead of killing her, he lifts her into his arms and says, “Let’s go home, Debbie.” This moment of unexpected grace is followed by The Searchers’ haunting final shot—Ethan standing alone in a doorway, isolated from the family he has reunited. Whether this act is enough to redeem him remains an open question, leaving the audience to interpret his fate.

 

The Searchers Inspired Some of the Greatest Films in Cinema History

 

Few films have had as lasting an impact as The Searchers. Its thematic and visual influence can be traced through some of the most revered movies of the past six decades.

Martin Scorsese’s Taxi Driver mirrors Ethan’s lonely, obsessive quest in its portrayal of Travis Bickle, a man spiraling into violence while attempting to “rescue” a young girl from a life of exploitation.

George Lucas has cited The Searchers as a key inspiration for Star Wars. The film’s famous scene of Ethan discovering his brother’s burned-out homestead is directly referenced in A New Hope, when Luke Skywalker returns to find his aunt and uncle’s home reduced to ashes by Imperial Stormtroopers. Lucas revisited this imagery in Attack of the Clones, with Anakin Skywalker’s discovery of his mother’s death at the hands of the Tusken Raiders, an event that triggers his own descent into vengeance.

When Wayne compiled his list of cinema’s greatest films, The Searchers stood out as his top Western pick. His choice aligned with the growing critical reevaluation of the film in the 1970s. Since then, it has consistently ranked among the greatest films ever made. Nearly 70 years after its release, The Searchers remains an enduring classic—a film of breathtaking artistry, moral complexity, and emotional weight.

Source: MovieWeb

Spread the love
Avatar photo
theGeek is here since 2019.

No comments

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

theGeek TV