Legal experts say Sony’s silence could become a serious problem, as the PS Store’s dynamic pricing system may conflict with at least two European Union directives. The PlayStation storefront may have been running a test for months that shows different users different prices for the same game, while the company has not given customers a clear explanation.
The digital video game market has been under scrutiny for years, not only because prices often spiral upward, but also because more and more players feel they are buying from a store governed by algorithms and rules that no one fully understands. In that context, it is especially sensitive that, over the past few months, it has emerged that Sony may be testing a dynamic pricing system on the PlayStation Store, one capable of showing one user a game at one price while showing the exact same title to someone else for less or more money.
Several reports suggest that Sony has been testing this kind of pricing on the PlayStation Store since late 2025, and legal experts warn that the strategy could have consequences within the European Union. An investigation by Danish outlet Arkaden, also reported by Eurogamer, warned that the company may be breaching Directive 2011/83/EU, which requires companies using personalised pricing to inform consumers “in a clear and understandable manner”.
Experts Say the Biggest Problem Is Not the Test, but the Silence
Based on the current reports, that disclosure has not happened. The system itself appears simple at first glance: according to PS Prices, users may be randomly assigned to control or test groups, and depending on the group they are placed in, they may see different prices for the same game. From a legal standpoint, the issue is not necessarily that a digital store is running a pricing test, but that customers are not being clearly told about it.
Law professor Jan Trzaskowski argues that the key point is that the user receives a specific price based on who they are, or on the group into which the system has placed them. “The problem is that you’re offered a specific price based on who you are. It doesn’t matter if you’ve been tracked across multiple platforms or if you’ve been included in a segment. The intent of the legislation favours a broad interpretation of automated decision-making in this context” – he explained. Sony could argue that it is not applying personalised pricing as such, but rather segmenting users into different groups, yet experts do not necessarily believe that distinction would protect the company.
Peter Rott, a law professor and co-author of a study on dynamic pricing, believes that in practice this distinction is not enough to satisfy EU requirements. He says this pricing method could also clash with Directive 2005/29/EC on unfair commercial practices, which essentially prohibits businesses from withholding important information that consumers need in order to decide whether or not to buy a product.
According to PS Prices, Sony’s test has been running since November 2025, and by March 2026 it may have covered more than 190 games across more than 70 regions, including the United States. The report says users were not necessarily being shown higher prices, but rather different levels of discounts: for some games, one customer could see a smaller discount while another saw a larger one. That, however, does not solve the transparency issue, because the buyer still does not know that they are part of a pricing experiment.
Christian Bergqvist, an associate professor at the University of Copenhagen, warned that in the worst-case scenario the company could face a fine. The situation is especially delicate because the PlayStation digital ecosystem has already faced heavy criticism in recent years over its closed store model, digital ownership and DRM-related controversies. If users are seeing different prices for the same game without a clear warning, the debate is no longer just about pricing policy – it may become a consumer protection issue as well.
Leave a Reply